Our Packing Is Already Complete; Will Shift The Very Next Day The House Is Ready
Thanks for studying this submit, do not forget to subscribe!
Former CJI DY Chandrachud responded to the bungalow controversy saying their packing is completed and so they’ll shift the subsequent day the home is prepared. He stated the allotted dwelling wants main repairs, which triggered the delay.
New Delhi: The Supreme Courtroom administration has instructed the federal government to make sure that former Chief Justice of India (CJI) D.Y. Chandrachud vacates his official bungalow in Lutyens’ Delhi. Justice Chandrachud clarified that he had obtained permission from Justice Sanjiv Khanna to stay there.
The Supreme Courtroom is requesting that former CJI D.Y. Chandrachud go away the official residence at 5 Krishna Menon Marg, which is designated for the present Chief Justice.
Justice Chandrachud talked about that Justice Sanjiv Khanna had granted him permission to remain till April. Attributable to his daughter’s particular wants, he sought an extension till June and in addition requested the federal government to help to find rented lodging.
Also Read: CJI Gavai Wants Ex-CJI Chandrachud To Be Removed Immediately?
Within the meantime, the Supreme Courtroom administration has urged the federal government to make sure that the bungalow is vacated promptly. This case has prompted varied questions, together with whether or not Justice Chandrachud was permitted to remain in violation of laws, if the federal government made any exceptions, and whether or not it’s appropriate for a former CJI to occupy an official residence for an prolonged interval.
Justice Chandrachud acknowledged to media,
“The federal government home allotted to me wants lots of restore. We’re ready for that work to be accomplished. As quickly as the home is prepared, we’ll instantly transfer in. Our packing is already full. The day the home is prepared, I’ll shift the very subsequent day.”
The Supreme Courtroom administration has requested the central authorities to make sure that the official bungalow designated for the Chief Justice is vacated immediately. Situated on Krishna Menon Marg in Lutyens’ Delhi, the bungalow is at present occupied by former CJI D.Y. Chandrachud, who retired in November of final 12 months.
Since this residence is meant for the sitting Chief Justice, the administration seeks to have it vacated promptly.
Justice Chandrachud shared his perspective with media, explaining that Justice Sanjiv Khanna had permitted him to remain till April. He later requested an extension till June because of the “particular wants” of his elder daughter, revealing that they’d established an ICU-like facility in the home for her care.
He added that he wrote to Justice Khanna on the finish of April, requesting permission to increase his keep till June resulting from his daughter’s well being points and in addition sought help from the federal government in securing rented lodging. He assured that he would transfer as quickly because the restore work was finalized.
Reviews point out that Justice D.Y. Chandrachud wrote to then CJI Sanjiv Khanna on December 18, 2024, a month after his retirement, looking for permission to stay within the Krishna Menon Marg bungalow till April 30, 2025.
In that correspondence, he famous that, in accordance with laws, he had been assigned one other residence (Bungalow No. 14 on Tughlaq Street). Nevertheless, because of the GRAP-IV air pollution management measures in Delhi, development was halted, stopping any repairs from commencing.
Also Read: 16 Key Constitutional Bench Rulings Under Ex CJI D.Y. Chandrachud
He talked about that it might be extra handy for him to remain within the present home till repairs had been accomplished. Moreover, he acknowledged that if one other choose required that home, he would vacate the Tughlaq Street residence.
In accordance with guidelines established in 2022, a retired CJI is allowed to occupy a Kind VII lodging (a smaller home) for six months after retirement. Nevertheless, Justice Chandrachud has been residing in a Kind VIII bungalow, which is often reserved for the sitting Chief Justice.
Justice Khanna granted his request, and subsequently, the Ministry of Housing and City Affairs accepted his continued keep. Consequently, he was formally allowed to reside on the Krishna Menon Marg bungalow from December 11, 2024, to April 30, 2025. This permission was conveyed to the Supreme Courtroom in a letter dated February 13, 2025.
- Firstly, the Supreme Courtroom is looking for the official CJI residence to be vacated.
- Secondly, Justice Chandrachud asserts that he prolonged his keep resulting from his daughter’s well being wants.
- Thirdly, in accordance with established guidelines, he ought to have been residing in a Kind VII lodging somewhat than a Kind VIII bungalow.
These circumstances have led to quite a few questions,
- Was Justice Chandrachud granted permission in violation of the foundations?
- Did the federal government make exceptions?
- Most critically, is it acceptable for a former CJI to occupy an official residence for an prolonged interval?
The solutions to those questions are nonetheless awaited. Nevertheless, this challenge raises a necessary concern: Are the foundations utilized equally to everybody within the nation, or do VIPs obtain particular remedy?
In an interview with media, Justice Chandrachud remarked,
“Justice Sanjiv Khanna had given me an extension until April. On the finish of April, I wrote to Justice Khanna once more, requesting an extension until June.”
Also Read: Ex-CJI D.Y. Chandrachud: “Do Not Confuse Law with Justice”
This means that Justice Khanna initially permitted him to remain till April, after which he sought extra time till June.
He added,
“We had been in search of a particular sort of home as a result of our daughters have particular wants. We created an ICU-like setup for our elder daughter, and so it’s onerous to discover a appropriate home within the open market. That’s why I requested the federal government to supply me non permanent rental lodging.”
These statements spotlight Justice Chandrachud’s real concern for his daughter’s well being and his preparations to maneuver quickly.
However, the basic query persists: Ought to he have been allowed to stay in an official residence for such an prolonged interval, probably in violation of laws?
